UK-China relations – no change, no apology


What we are seeing in news reports about UK-China relations, initially published in Xinhua (the Chinese state-run news agency) and then taken up by The Telegraph, which ran a piece featured in its financial pages written by Liu Xiaming, China’s Ambassador to the UK, is no more and no less than PR spin by China. It is smoke and mirrors, attempting to persuade people that something has changed in UK-China relations so an invitation can be extended to David Cameron to visit Beijing in the autumn without any loss of face.

The truth is there has been no change in British policy on Tibet; David Cameron has not apologised to China for meeting the Dalai Lama when he was in London last year, the government’s stand on Tibet being part of the People’s Republic of China remains unaltered, and recently on Sky News Nick Clegg asserted the UK would not back down from confronting China on human rights issues.

The Dalai Lama meeting David Cameron and Nick Clegg, May 2012

The Dalai Lama meeting David Cameron and Nick Clegg, May 2012

Despite the UK’s “very important” economic relationship with China, Mr Clegg said, “That doesn’t mean we should somehow give up on what we believe in when it comes to human rights and freedoms which we will continue to express in a respectful but nonetheless firm way.” And, as detailed by Liu Xiaoming in his article, it seems despite the UK’s adherence to human rights and freedoms and despite the apparent frozen relations between the UK and China, trade has not only continued unhindered, but has grown.

The Chinese government is pragmatic; they need trading relations to flourish in order to keep their population, who are expecting uninterrupted economic growth, happy. However, at the same time, they are not averse to trying their hand in bullying countries into accepting their viewpoint on all manner of issues, including when a leader of a country can and cannot meet the Dalai Lama. It is a game, albeit one that can have far-reaching consequences. But our government, and other governments, can and should do more to stand up to China’s flannel, stop kowtowing to its whims and use their influence to encourage China to bring real change in key areas of human rights and freedoms and rule of law.

Liu Xiaoming

Liu Xiaoming

In his article, Liu Xiaoming says, “Six months ago, I was interviewed on the BBC’s Newsnight by Gavin Esler. He quoted Rudyard Kipling’s famous phrase: “East is East, West is West, and never the twain shall meet.” I replied that the right way for East and West to meet is to “discard pride and prejudice and apply sense and sensibility.” I believe this is also the right way for China and Britain to meet and work for an even brighter future for Anglo-Chinese relations.”

Very nice sentiments, but will Liu Xiaoming and his colleagues in Beijing follow this belief and “discard prejudice and apply sense and sensibility”? If they did, there really could be progress on Tibet and for other minorities suffering under China’s rule.

Further reading:
24/6: British foreign secretary reiterates respect for China’s territorial integrity
The Telegraph

27/6: Cameron’s words to MPs have opened door to better relations!
27/6: 2 million ‘displaced’ by Chinese relocation policy
28/6: China and Britain have their differences but they also have a lot to offer each other
28/6: China may be softening on HHDL
Tibet Society
8/5: China seeks apology from UK; Clegg says UK must stand firm
9/5: Cameron: UK government “does not support Tibetan independence”
3/7: Hague smooths path for Cameron to visit Beijing


About tibetsociety

Founded in 1959, within weeks of the flight of the Dalai Lama from Tibet following the uprising against China's occupation, Tibet Society became the world’s first ever Tibet support group. Today, Tibet Society continues to work for the freedom of the Tibetan people and their right to self-determination.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s